handcrafted for saint louis
at nilla cookie co, we create cookies that look beautiful, taste incredible, and make every celebration feel a little more special. from custom-decorated designs to fresh-baked classics, everything is crafted in our saint louis cottage bakery with care and attention to detail.
custom decorated cookies
beautifully designed sugar cookies tailored for your event. each cookie is handcrafted with meticulous detail to match your theme, making every celebration feel personal and memorable.
reach out to start planning the perfect set for your next event.
starting at $60/dozen
fresh baked drop cookies
classic, soft cookies baked fresh in small batches. perfect for everyday treats or sharing with the people you love.
reach out to explore our favorite cookie options.
starting at $24/dozen
seasonal specials
limited-time treats inspired by the flavors and moments of each season. from festive holiday cookies to small-batch specialty bakes, these offerings bring a touch of celebration to everyday life.
reach out to see what’s currently baking for the season.
home made bakes
small-batch baked goods made with the same care and warmth you’d find in a home kitchen. from coffee cake to cinnamon rolls and more, these treats are crafted to bring comfort to any moment.
reach out to order your favorite home-style bake.
Brian R.
"I just devoured a White Chocolate Macadamia Nut cookie. Best cookie I’ve ever had! And I have had my share of cookies in my day. I told my wife it was so good it was almost fake. Like being at Disney World or walking through the streets of Venice, Italy. Not sure how they do it, but please don’t stop!"
Julie B.
"The cookies from Nilla Cookie Co are fantastic!! We had chocolate chip and butter pecan which were excellent. The decorated cookies looked so amazing, I was very impressed. Tasted great too. You won't be disappointed!"
testimonials
Cindy R.
"Taylor makes THE most delicious cookies I’ve ever had. Not only are they so yummy, they truly are a work of art. The detail, the creativity, the flavor - exceptional! And her customer service is off the charts. I highly, highly recommend ordering these amazing cookies for your next party or event - or just because!"
Jordan S.
"The cookies are not only beautiful, they are also delicious! Taylor is great at catering to exactly what you want & making your ideas come to life. She is professional & prompt. Couldn’t recommend her more!"