the goods

custom decorated sugar cookies

our decorated cookies are available in three levels of detail, from simple designs to highly customized artwork. Pricing varies based on the tier and design complexity.

tier 1 - basic

typically features two additional colors and one-three cookie shapes.

$65 / dozen

tier 2 - detailed

typically includes three-four additional colors and three-five cookie shapes.

$70 / dozen

tier 3 - elaborate

typically uses four or more colors and four or more cookie shapes.

$75+ / dozen

fresh baked drop cookies

our classic drop cookies are baked fresh in small batches and offered in a variety of flavors. they’re available in regular 2 oz cookies or jumbo 4 oz cookies, making them perfect for everyday treats, sharing, or gifting.

  • chocolate chip

  • sugar cookie

  • snickerdoodle

  • oatmeal raisin

  • butter pecan chocolate chip

  • butter pecan

  • white chocolate macadamia

  • cherry white chocolate

  • ginger molasses

  • gooey butter cookie

  • chai sugar

  • chocolate crinkle

  • and more! (reach out with any requests)

regular size (2 oz) - $30 / dozen

jumbo size (4 oz) - $60 / dozen

place an order

thank you for shopping local!

fill out the form with as much detail as possible, including your event date, theme, colors, and any special requests.

once submitted, we'll follow up to confirm details, pricing, availability, and next steps. Most custom orders involve a bit of back-and-forth to make sure everything is just right.

all cookies are packaged in food-safe bags and boxes to maintain freshness unless otherwise requested.

full payment or a deposit may be required to secure your event date, and we recommend placing orders as early as possible due to limited availability.

saint louis, missouri

nillacookieco@gmail.com